According to Mass Live, a jogger discovered Chicklis' body on the side of Route 119 on July 10, 2018, in New Hampshire. The body was reportedly wrapped in a tarp, blanket, and canvas sheet. Chicklis and Enright reportedly rode the bus together to Montachusett Regional Vocational Technical School and started dating.
Chicklis was reportedly stabbed over a dozen times in Enright’s treehouse, Mass Live reports. Prosecutors argued Enright killed him as a "surprise gift" for her boyfriend at the time. They also said they found evidence Enright wrote about an "insatiable curiosity to kill a person" and found wet specimens in her bedroom. She also reportedly worked as a dominatrix on the side. Enright’s attorney, however, said she killed Chicklis in self-defense because he raped her.
Enright said at her sentencing hearing, "There is not a day that goes by that don’t think about this or don’t wish I could go back. Maybe you need to hear me say this: I’m sorry to everyone. His parents, his siblings, his loved ones, my parents, friends, everyone."