A responding officer saw a motorcycle with a passenger carrying an aquarium pass him on Route 46 and turned around to give chase.
According to police, the passenger got off the motorcycle with the aquarium and began running on West Street, breaking the aquarium.
Police say a few minutes later the motorcycle was found on the ground. When officers began to search the area, they found a man they described as "nervous looking" behind a home on Franklin Street.
Officers said the man began to furiously prune a small tree with his bare hands and told officers he was there to do yard work. He also told the officers the suspect ran east.
Christopher Binion pleaded not guilty to charges of theft, fleeing and eluding and multiple traffic charges. Bond was set at $100,000. Mitchell Adkins pleaded not guilty to theft charges. His bond was set at $25,000. Adkins is due back in court on August 8. Binion is scheduled to appear on August 1.