Reichel, who like many have followed the case from the beginning, says the old police reports may simply spark speculation about Papini's character.
"There's no drama like family drama, and she may have had some serious drama with her family 13 years earlier," Reichel said.
FOX40 also obtained documents showing in November of last year, days after Papini vanished, two detectives from the Shasta County Sheriff's Office traveled to Detroit, Michigan, for three days for "investigative purposes."
The sheriff's office remains tight-lipped about the investigation, which is ongoing and active.
"This is very far from over, and it is going to get even more interesting, how can it not?" said Reichel.